I've compiled a list today, categorized and on top of all got alexa ranking for each of 45 forums. I included SEO, webmastering, affiliate, marketing domains and blogging forums.

Netvestor Top Webmaster Forum List

If you like it give it a stumble or sphinn

You're on it.

All you've done is sorted them by alexa rank and said that the forum with the highest rank is the best, which is hardly the case. Don't you think that that's a little arbitrary?

Originally Posted by NullPointer

All you've done is sorted them by alexa rank and said that the forum with the highest rank is the best, which is hardly the case. Don't you think that that's a little arbitrary?

How dare you to doubt "authenticity" of Alexa’s Rating?
Don’t you know that every 1 person in 10,000 use Alexa’s ToolBar because
they are know that Alexa don’t sucks (oh well, [unnecessary comment deleted to keep forum with General rating]) and that without Alexa Internet will cease to exist?

You should know that by now


fastreplies

Placing Digital Point at the top of the list (and having webmaster-talk at position number 17) pretty much destroys the credibility of the list.

I did not say that they are sorted from best to worst (they are sorted by alexa). Read the title again it says worlds best webmaster forums and I am sure your favorite is in the list Peace

Making the list's Alexa rank and num. position sort exactly the same implies the list is ranked that way.

(Also, some others might not know where to click right away, as there's no rollover action)

Of course, this thread could be taken as spam since it was only to advertise a specific site, of which belongs to the thread originator.

One external link to go, please.

Dave

Excellent list Thanks a million.....

Originally Posted by odysseus

Excellent list Thanks a million.....

Just another **** is marking territory






fastreplies

The list implies the one with the best Alexa rank is the best forum.

Originally Posted by jamestl2

Placing Digital Point at the top of the list (and having webmaster-talk at position number 17) pretty much destroys the credibility of the list.

Webmaster talk as an alexa rank of 8,254 - also DP is the largest forum.

Oh well, Whatever rank it is, the important thing is that people in the forums could get help or share ideas and could be of help to others most specially the newbies...

Originally Posted by cpvr

Webmaster talk as an alexa rank of 8,254 - also DP is the largest forum.

Are you saying that size and rank are related? Explain why there are forums
on that list that are higher ranking than WT with half as many members/posts.
Most of us know how easy it is to manipulate alexa rank.

Originally Posted by zeruel

Oh well, Whatever rank it is, the important thing is that people in the forums could get help or share ideas and could be of help to others most specially the newbies...

That's actually a decent point, zeruel.
Larger forums, such as DigitalPointless, are so active that many legitimate posts
go unnoticed because they get buried under tons of crap posts.

I agree that zeruel has a good point. The reason I stayed with Webmaster-Talk is people get help with their questions.

I used to frequent a Linux forum and if your question was a few hours old, it was on the second page already.

Originally Posted by Moxxnixx

That's actually a decent point, zeruel.
Larger forums, such as DigitalPointless, are so active that many legitimate posts
go unnoticed because they get buried under tons of crap posts.

I definitely agree with you also on this. A lot of buried thread with no replies happens mostly on some forums... Which is I think not good to the thread starter most specially if he/she is asking for something important and needs advice...

lol nice trick for revenue should i propz lol?

Originally Posted by Moxxnixx

That's actually a decent point, zeruel.
Larger forums, such as DigitalPointless, are so active that many legitimate posts
go unnoticed because they get buried under tons of crap posts.

Hmm.. so you mean to say that a forum gained their Alexa because of
posting a crap posts? Or maybe because the forum is more populated
than the other?

Originally Posted by Cryxellis

Hmm.. so you mean to say that a forum gained their Alexa because of
posting a crap posts? Or maybe because the forum is more populated
than the other?

Neither.
Alexa had absolutely nothing to do with with my remark to zeruel.