Tycoon Talk
Become a Big fish!
The number 1 forum for online business!
Post topics, ask questions, share your knowledge.
Tycoon Talk is part of Freelancer.com - find skilled workers online at a fraction of the cost.

Graphics Forum


You are currently viewing our Graphics Forum as a guest. Please register to participate.
Login



Reply
Whats better PNG or GIF for transparent index buttons?
Old 06-05-2008, 08:57 AM Whats better PNG or GIF for transparent index buttons?
CircleOfLinks's Avatar
Extreme Talker

Posts: 243
Name: Danny
Location: Sydney
Trades: 1
Hey guys im just wondering what would be better for index buttins??
should I use PNG or GIF? The reasom im asking is becuase everytime I save a GIF file with a transparent back ground using Photoshop CS2 the font goes a little 'rough' but when I save it as a PNG file it saves ok. So im wondering do all browsers read png??
by the way the font im using to is just standard ARIAL so its nothing special...
thanks heaps
__________________
Danny

Please login or register to view this content. Registration is FREE
|
Please login or register to view this content. Registration is FREE
CircleOfLinks is offline
Reply With Quote
View Public Profile Visit CircleOfLinks's homepage!
 
 
Register now for full access!
Old 06-05-2008, 09:59 AM Re: Whats better PNG or GIF for transparent index buttons?
Renset's Avatar
Skilled Talker

Posts: 66
Name: Renat
Location: Russia
Trades: 0
Hi, CircleOfLinks,
PNG — is a newer graphics format and it is some better that gif. PNG-24 have best transparent, but Internet Explorer 6 don't support it's transparent. PNG don't support animation. PNG-8 (256 colors) look like as GIF-8 but have less size
__________________

Please login or register to view this content. Registration is FREE
(Now on russian only and supports last versions of browsers (not Internet Explorer 6) )



Last edited by Renset; 06-05-2008 at 10:00 AM..
Renset is offline
Reply With Quote
View Public Profile
 
Old 06-05-2008, 10:25 AM Re: Whats better PNG or GIF for transparent index buttons?
LadynRed's Avatar
Defies a Status

Posts: 10,016
Location: Tennessee
Trades: 0
PNG is the best transparency by far over GIFs. IE6 doesn't support transparent PNG's without a bit of scripting to force it and it still won't support a repeating transparent PNGs. So it would be good for buttons, not good for backgrounds (in IE6).

As for your text, make sure you have your anti-aliasing turned on.
__________________
Web Goddess & Web Standards Evangelist :) - Tables Be Gone !!

Please login or register to view this content. Registration is FREE


Please login or register to view this content. Registration is FREE

LadynRed is offline
Reply With Quote
View Public Profile
 
Old 06-05-2008, 11:08 AM Re: Whats better PNG or GIF for transparent index buttons?
CircleOfLinks's Avatar
Extreme Talker

Posts: 243
Name: Danny
Location: Sydney
Trades: 1
LadynRed how do i turn it on? i can't find the option...
__________________
Danny

Please login or register to view this content. Registration is FREE
|
Please login or register to view this content. Registration is FREE
CircleOfLinks is offline
Reply With Quote
View Public Profile Visit CircleOfLinks's homepage!
 
Old 06-05-2008, 11:20 AM Re: Whats better PNG or GIF for transparent index buttons?
CircleOfLinks's Avatar
Extreme Talker

Posts: 243
Name: Danny
Location: Sydney
Trades: 1
ladynred ive turned it on but its still doing it... got any other sujjstions?
__________________
Danny

Please login or register to view this content. Registration is FREE
|
Please login or register to view this content. Registration is FREE
CircleOfLinks is offline
Reply With Quote
View Public Profile Visit CircleOfLinks's homepage!
 
Old 06-05-2008, 11:48 AM Re: Whats better PNG or GIF for transparent index buttons?
Renset's Avatar
Skilled Talker

Posts: 66
Name: Renat
Location: Russia
Trades: 0
« PNG is the best transparency by far over GIFs. IE6 doesn't support transparent PNG's without a bit of scripting to force it and it still won't support a repeating transparent PNGs. So it would be good for buttons, not good for backgrounds (in IE6).


As for your text, make sure you have your anti-aliasing turned on.»


It is 100% plagiarism.
__________________

Please login or register to view this content. Registration is FREE
(Now on russian only and supports last versions of browsers (not Internet Explorer 6) )



Last edited by Renset; 06-05-2008 at 11:51 AM..
Renset is offline
Reply With Quote
View Public Profile
 
Old 06-05-2008, 11:56 AM Re: Whats better PNG or GIF for transparent index buttons?
Renset's Avatar
Skilled Talker

Posts: 66
Name: Renat
Location: Russia
Trades: 0
I thought, Americans are good people. But they take another's ideas, and write their in correct language. Australians agree with Americans even if they are not right. All hate Russians. Why?
__________________

Please login or register to view this content. Registration is FREE
(Now on russian only and supports last versions of browsers (not Internet Explorer 6) )


Renset is offline
Reply With Quote
View Public Profile
 
Old 06-05-2008, 12:28 PM Re: Whats better PNG or GIF for transparent index buttons?
Renset's Avatar
Skilled Talker

Posts: 66
Name: Renat
Location: Russia
Trades: 0
johar75, CircleOfLinks, For antialiasing you should find list with antialiasing variants near by Font-size list in Photoshop. If you use gif-8 or png-8, antialiasing doesn't help you if your text is placed on transparent background.
__________________

Please login or register to view this content. Registration is FREE
(Now on russian only and supports last versions of browsers (not Internet Explorer 6) )



Last edited by Renset; 06-05-2008 at 12:41 PM..
Renset is offline
Reply With Quote
View Public Profile
 
Old 06-05-2008, 06:37 PM Re: Whats better PNG or GIF for transparent index buttons?
LadynRed's Avatar
Defies a Status

Posts: 10,016
Location: Tennessee
Trades: 0
Quote:
It is 100% plagiarism.
What ARE you talking about ?? I copied NO ONE Renset.. and I don't give a flip where you're from !

Johar75, if you're going to use PNG8 or GIF, you have to specify a MATTE color, otherwise anti-aliasing still won't look right. If you use PNG24, you won't need a matte color when you 'save for web'
__________________
Web Goddess & Web Standards Evangelist :) - Tables Be Gone !!

Please login or register to view this content. Registration is FREE


Please login or register to view this content. Registration is FREE


Last edited by LadynRed; 06-06-2008 at 04:22 PM..
LadynRed is offline
Reply With Quote
View Public Profile
 
Old 06-05-2008, 09:21 PM Re: Whats better PNG or GIF for transparent index buttons?
CircleOfLinks's Avatar
Extreme Talker

Posts: 243
Name: Danny
Location: Sydney
Trades: 1
Hey what did Johar75 say?? it got deleted before i read it??

Ok, well for some reason I cant actully turn on/off antialiasing its not an option, I can see it but can't do anything to it... But if I save a file with a transparency using 'save for web' PNG8 would that work in IE6 and FF and most browswers, everyone is saying PNG wont work in IE6 but how about FF1 & FF2 plus other browsers??

1 last thing regarding the 'save for web' should I have the interlaced option on or off??
__________________
Danny

Please login or register to view this content. Registration is FREE
|
Please login or register to view this content. Registration is FREE

Last edited by CircleOfLinks; 06-05-2008 at 09:23 PM.. Reason: spelling mistake (bad one thoe)
CircleOfLinks is offline
Reply With Quote
View Public Profile Visit CircleOfLinks's homepage!
 
Old 06-06-2008, 04:24 PM Re: Whats better PNG or GIF for transparent index buttons?
LadynRed's Avatar
Defies a Status

Posts: 10,016
Location: Tennessee
Trades: 0
IE6 is the only browser in the current crop that does NOT support PNG transparency natively. PNG8 is really no better than GIF. I'd go for PNG24, use the PNG fix to make IE6 behave and you should be good.

Leave the interlaced option OFF, you don't want that.
__________________
Web Goddess & Web Standards Evangelist :) - Tables Be Gone !!

Please login or register to view this content. Registration is FREE


Please login or register to view this content. Registration is FREE

LadynRed is offline
Reply With Quote
View Public Profile
 
Old 06-06-2008, 06:24 PM Re: Whats better PNG or GIF for transparent index buttons?
Super Moderator

Posts: 1,576
Location: Kokkola, Finland
Trades: 1
a link to the page would help in seeing whether it's necessary to use png 24 ( if i'm not mistaken i think we're talking about png 32 here: 24bit plus 8 bit transparency i.e. alpha transparency) or whether gif/8-bit png would suffice
davemies is offline
Reply With Quote
View Public Profile Visit davemies's homepage!
 
Reply     « Reply to Whats better PNG or GIF for transparent index buttons?
 

Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are Off
Pingbacks are Off
Refbacks are Off





   
RSS Feed  Feeds: RSS   JS   XML
RSS Feed  Feeds for this forum: RSS   JS   XML



Page generated in 0.33376 seconds with 12 queries