There are so many classifieds sites it's not funny. They can work, though.
One tip I would give is that you should post to the ones that repeatedly appear highest in the search engine rankings, because these are the ones getting indexed. (Obvious really.)
Post your ads to a few of those. Then a couple of weeks later do a search for some of the terms in your ads. You should see some of them come up. This would suggest that those sites are the best to post to next time.
I think this should help improve the response rate a little.