Tycoon Talk
Become a Big fish!
The number 1 forum for online business!
Post topics, ask questions, share your knowledge.
Tycoon Talk is part of Freelancer.com - find skilled workers online at a fraction of the cost.

The Google Forum


You are currently viewing our The Google Forum as a guest. Please register to participate.
Login



Reply
Would this be a bad idea?
Old 02-27-2008, 01:29 AM Would this be a bad idea?
ForrestCroce's Avatar
Half Man, Half Amazing

Posts: 3,023
Name: Forrest Croce
Location: Seattle, WA
Trades: 0
Last spring, Matt Cutts pointed out that it's a violation of Google's quality guidelines to allow your internal search results to be indexed. ( See: Search results in search results. ) Murphy being an optimist, I wind up with my own search results in Google's index. A lot of them, according to the site: query option.

I've blocked these in robots.txt, and nofollowed some of the similar links. The search form uses a get, so there are no links ... meaning there have to be external links for Google to know about the pages. I don't know php well enough to hack my particular wordpress template to add a meta tag for robots to the search piece of the code ... although I might wind up learning.

It would be a lot easier to just use .htaccess; if the user agent is googlebot, and the request is to a search, I can redirect to the home page, or some arbitrary url that can be indexed. That sounds a lot like cloaking, although it's the least effort to implement. In theory you aren't supposed to do anything solely for a search engine's benefit, but I don't personally care whether my /index.php?s= pages are being indexed.
__________________

Please login or register to view this content. Registration is FREE
|
Please login or register to view this content. Registration is FREE
|
Please login or register to view this content. Registration is FREE
ForrestCroce is offline
Reply With Quote
View Public Profile Visit ForrestCroce's homepage!
 
 
Register now for full access!
Old 02-27-2008, 02:02 AM Re: Would this be a bad idea?
ADAM Web Design's Avatar
Canadastaninianite

Posts: 5,938
Name: Adam for web page design, not program
Location: Toronto, Ontario, Canada
Trades: 0
Hey dude,

The problem with your idea is that indexing searches would end up indexing content that is already indexed in other spots on your site (i.e. duplicate content). You'd open yourself to anyone who did a category search on your blog (photographer competitor with just enough SEO knowledge to be dangerous).

I'd just leave it as is. If they're blocked from being indexed, they're blocked.
__________________

Please login or register to view this content. Registration is FREE
|
Please login or register to view this content. Registration is FREE
(my blog)


Please login or register to view this content. Registration is FREE
(with proof)
ADAM Web Design is offline
Reply With Quote
View Public Profile Visit ADAM Web Design's homepage!
 
Old 02-27-2008, 03:11 AM Re: Would this be a bad idea?
ForrestCroce's Avatar
Half Man, Half Amazing

Posts: 3,023
Name: Forrest Croce
Location: Seattle, WA
Trades: 0
I thought I solved this a few months ago. When I search for the exact url to one of the search pages, I get no results. Any thoughts on how I might find out where Google is finding links to my search pages? A lot are searches for things like 'ish' and 'blog' so it can only be spam.

That won't fix the situation with Google. I'm sure it's not really a problem, but good citizenship and all...

I've had this in my robots.txt forever:
Quote:
User-agent: *
Disallow: */tag/
Disallow: *index.php?s=
I went through a page of my internal search pages showing up in a site: search and put them into the url removal form ... but as a developer, I'm compelled to find a better way.
__________________

Please login or register to view this content. Registration is FREE
|
Please login or register to view this content. Registration is FREE
|
Please login or register to view this content. Registration is FREE
ForrestCroce is offline
Reply With Quote
View Public Profile Visit ForrestCroce's homepage!
 
Reply     « Reply to Would this be a bad idea?
 

Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are Off
Pingbacks are Off
Refbacks are Off





   
RSS Feed  Feeds: RSS   JS   XML
RSS Feed  Feeds for this forum: RSS   JS   XML



Page generated in 0.35872 seconds with 12 queries