Orodreth, perhaps I wasn't 100% clear... I will clarify my point with respect to the affiliate link issue.
The problem is that affiliate schemes encourage people to recommend for the wrong reasons - this doesn't mean that you personally are doing so, but it is a fact that it happens.
My personal opinion (doesn't mean anyone needs to agree with it) is that recommendations should be based on positive personal experience with that provider. Obviously this is what users are looking for when they ask for help, and for them, I would suggest that selecting which people are genuinely trying to help is best done by ignoring those who stand to gain from it - i.e. if someone strongly recommends a hosting provider with an affiliate link or similar for them, that user will gain in some way from offering that "advice", so it may not be genuine?
In your particular post above I would have expected someone looking to be helpful (vs. get an affiliate signup) to post the standard link instead of just point to their sig., and explicitly state that if they wish to follow your advice that you would appreciate them using the link in your sig. so that you both benefit etc.
In other words, affiliate schemes themselves are part of the issue (because I don't believe that it encourages honest recommendations), but the other part is that I would prefer you to be very clear, open, and honest that the link in your sig. is an affiliate link (especially when directing people towards it) instead of relying on the user to figure it out and avoid if they wish etc.
Does that make it any clearer?
I encourage everyone who has good things to say about any provider to speak up, but it annoys me when hosts get good press because they offer certain incentives for doing so. I accept it may not be the case in this instance, but it just felt like it 
__________________
Please login or register to view this content. Registration is FREE :: DDS & Dedicated, UK & USA-based Please login or register to view this content. Registration is FREE, Reseller & Shared Hosting
Experienced Parallels Platinum Partners (Plesk since 2001, Virtuozzo since 2003)
|