I definatly think you're moving in the right direction, you've added more color for sure.
I'm not sure how I feel about the tiled backgrounds, they make the site look very mid '90s.
I still think you need to add more images to the site. The homepage especially needs images, you need to grab the visitor's attention, and text alone just isn't going to do it. Choose some of your favorite knife images and try and work one or two into each page.
You should definatly customize the look of your forum to fit the final design of your site.
This is the number one site that Google returned when I searched for "pocket knives" http://www.sarcoknives.com although it doesn't have a lot of pictures, the interface has a very elegant, refined look to it. I think if you can find a happy medium between what you have, and the Sarco site, you would be in good shape.
Presentation is everything on the web, if people don't like what they see, there are millions of other sites for them to go to.
|